The Great Pie Sale

It’s time for the Great Pie Sale – homemade pies are the best! Our homemade pies are lovingly made by our friends at Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop and Windy Knoll Farm Market & Creamery. Flavors include:

• Apple
• Blueberry
• Cherry (Sweet)
• Chocolate Cream
• Lemon Meringue
• Mince Meat
• Peach (NEW FOR 2025!)
• Pecan
• Pumpkin
• Shoo-fly
• Sugar Free Apple
• Sugar Free Cherry
• Pumpkin Roll (from Windy Knoll Farm Market & Creamery)
• Peanut Butter (made by Windy Knoll Farm Market & Creamery)
• Coconut Cream Pie (made by Windy Knoll Farm Market & Creamery)

ORDER PICK-UP PROCESS

General Customer Orders (Pick Up ONLY)
General pie orders should be picked up on Tuesday, November 25, 2025 between 3:30 pm and 7:00 pm at Antrim Brethren in Christ Church - 24 Kauffman Rd E, Chambersburg, PA.

Business/Organization Orders (Delivery ONLY for 10 or More Pies)
If you are ordering for a business, orders of 10 pies or more can be scheduled to be delivered to your business on Wednesday, November 26, 2025 between 9:00 am and Noon. Call the school for details: 717.375.2223. If you are a business ordering less than 10 pies, you must place a general order and pick up your pies at Antrim BIC.

All orders are online only. If you need assistance please call the office at 717.375.2223. If you have any questions, please email piesale@shalomca.com.

DEADLINE EXTENDED: orders are due by Wednesday, November 12, 2025 at 5:00 pm. 
No pie orders will be accepted after the deadline. Thank you for understanding.